Home Reviews Top 10 Best Dog Training Collars Safe for Dogs

Top 10 Best Dog Training Collars Safe for Dogs

Quality dog training collars with 100% accuracy and precision are the safest option for obedience training.


Any new pet owner's first goal is to learn how to train a dog and do it effectively. Positive reinforcement is used as the primary tool for training since all shock collars for dogs have been unfairly demonized. However, evidence shows that not all dogs can be easily trained without help, and Best Dog Training Collars Safe for Dogssafely utilizing one of the best dog training collars can improve effectiveness and reduce stress of training for the dog.

Many pet owners remain skeptical of these devices, and rightfully so. There are a lot of very low-quality shock collars for dogs that can potentially hurt pets while training, but we've also seen mobile phones explode while talking on them. This doesn't mean we should stop using mobile phones; we just need to avoid defective devices.

After discussing this with many dog trainers and doing a thorough research of the shock collar market, we've found some of the best dog training collars that have proven to be effective and safe for training dogs. In this article, we're looking at some of the top rated options, including these five best training collars that have won the hearts of many pet owners:

Dog Training Collars Price Quality Rating
Educator ET-302-2T-CP Two Dog, Two Transmitter E-Collar $$$$$ A++ 4.8/5
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425 $$$ A- 4.6/5
Dogtra Fieldmaster 1 Dog LCD Collar $$$$ B 4.4/5
Dogtra 1902NCP Remote 2-dog Collar $$$$ B 4.4/5
Garmin Delta XC Bundle Device $$ C 3.9/5

* Click on the best dog training collars for more information, prices and details. Alternatively, scroll below to read reviews and more.

Using best dog training collars safely and effectively

The effectiveness of high quality best dog training collars is indisputable, provided a dog owner understands the device's purpose and how to use it properly. Unfortunately, in the last five years, the market got flooded with poor quality shock collars for dogs, which rapidly raised red flags among owners and labeled the whole industry evil and all training collars harmful.

Best Dog Training Collars Safe for DogsThat is completely incorrect, however. The fact is if the owner uses high-quality device, there's no risk for the dog. We recommend reading our interview with a professional dog trainer where he explains more on why it's okay to use these devices.

Certain dog training collars (e.g. Educator, the number #1 on the list) use proprietary technology that simply releases a pulsation which gets the dog's attention but doesn't actually harm the animal, and thereby are completely safe. Many other high-quality devices mentioned on this list of best dog training collars are also totally safe for dogs.

What Are the Best Dog Training Collars?
2017's top 10 best training collars for dogs that are safe

1Educator ET-302-2T-CP Two Dog, Two Transmitter

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsEducator is a dog company that specializes specifically in safe and human shock collars for dogs. According to the manufacturer themselves as well as a multitude of feedback from dog owners, the company invests a lot into research and proper manufacturing practices to ensure accuracy and safety of their dog training collars. When compared to household names such as Dogtra, SportDog or Garmin, the line of products from Educator easily stands up to these famous brands.

The reason Educator ended up as the first choice on our list of best dog training collar is not only the quality, safety and proven efficacy of their shock collar for dogs, but also due to company's ability to focus on one specific technology and not get distracted with other potential products. It seems that this strategy has been working well for Educator, as their expertise in shock collars for dogs is quickly making their name in the industry as true experts of canine training equipment.

We fully assemble each Educator dog training collar and test all of our products in the USA.” – Educator

So let's talk about the Educator ET-302-2T-CP itself and why it may be the best dog training collar to train your dog. This is a two dog system that has been proven to improve effectiveness of training a dog, and reduce the stress of the training process itself. The reason is their proprietary technology which produces lowest levels of blunt stimulus, which is more like a vibration rather than a shock, and thereby reliably and safely educating the dog on proper behavior without physically or mentally hurting the canine.

Best Shock Collars for Dogs - Educator Reviews

The receiver of Educator e-collar dog trainer is small enough that it can be usable for dogs five pounds and larger. It actually comfortably fits in your hand, and even looks good. There are different sensations associated with this shock dog collar, from a vibration sensation to a corrective one and the levels are adjustable from 1 to 100 with an additional “boost stimulus” which can be selected from the range of 1 to 60. The design is similar to a stopwatch, so you’re able to keep your eye on your dog instead of staring down at the collar and back up.

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsThe only drawback of this collar is the battery life. Although its usually enough, owners who are looking for something to last them on long trips or very long training sessions will probably be disappointed in how quickly the batteries discharge.

The reason batteries discharge quick is this device's accurate stimulus technology, which taxes the battery a lot more to ensure precision and accurate of safe vibrations to the dog. However, I find that having a dual battery charger with Educator ET-302-2T-CP actually helps and overall is a good deal.

Finally, a price can be a deterrent for some. Even though the device is absolutely worth its cost, not every owner will be able to afford their most high end product. Fortunately, the company has several versions of their Educator dog training collar, some of which are cheaper. We'll list those below for anybody interested in alternatives. Cheaper versions don't have as many features and options, but the proprietary technology remains the same – they're still the safest dog shock collars for training a canine.

“Educator has developed the most reliable and fastest wireless link in the dog training collar industry.”

Top five best features of Educator dog training collar:

  1. New technology proven to increase effectiveness and reduce stress
  2. Safety: it delivers a sensation that is similar to a vibration
  3. Very ergonomic and innovative design of the receiver
  4. Sourced, assembled, made and tested in the USA (no China relations)
  5. A variety of features to improve effectiveness and user-friendliness

Best Shock Collar for Dogs ReviewAs you can see, the main benefit of using Educator ET-302-2T-CP is primarily the safety and effectiveness for training dogs. I highly advise anybody getting ready to learn how to train a dog and wanting to using shock collars for dogs to simply research this company further, visit their website, inquire them about their products to make sure you know in who's hands you're putting your dog's health and safety. You'll be pleasantly surprised with the company's customer service and the way they conduct their business.


  • Proprietary technology
  • Most safe and effective shock collar
  • Best-seller on Amazon
  • Waterproof, floating with tracking light
  • 2-year money back warranty
  • Top notch customer service

  • Expensive
  • Battery life

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“I was given a 6 month old Doberman who had been through multiple owners because he was “high energy, unruly, uncontrollable.” That may sound like most dogs but this went to the point…”


2SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer SD-425

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsThe second on our list of best dog training collars is from a famous company in this industry, SportDOG. Every dog owner who spent some time either training a dog or hunting with a dog using the help of these electronic devices knows about SportDOG.

This company has made a name for themselves quite a while ago, and still maintain a great reputation among dog owners to this day. Their products are popular among pet owners and professionals alike, and all you have to do is take a look at the reviews.

As for this specific unit, SportDOG SD-425 has been one of the most popular shock collars for dogs on the market for a while, until the above mentioned Educator has finally took a huge bite of SportDOG's and many other brands' pie. Nonetheless, the SD-425 still remains one of the best dog training collars for a very affordable price under $170, especially when compared to the premium quality shock collars for dogs which often range from $300 and upwards.

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsSome of the best features SportDOG SD-425 can offer a dog owner who'd like to use it for training a pet is its long-distance, which is about 500 yards. Its precise seven levels of low to medium stimulation ensures effective yet safe approach to canine training, and this device also expands to 3 dogs if you get their SDR-AF package (look on the product's page for more details).

For owners who are interested in training in rain, or going hunting, or otherwise find a reason to get themselves and their dog wet, this is a completely waterproof dog training collar and is very ergonomic, easy to use.

Overall, this is arguably the best deal in terms of price-to-value ratio. Dog owners who cannot afford the premium and more expensive Educator unit listed above should definitely look into SportDOG SD-425 as a viable alternative for half the price. It doesn't carry the superior technology of Educator, but it's good enough for many dog trainers to recommend as a safe tool for training dogs.


  • Reputable company
  • Affordable
  • Long-time popular dog collar
  • 500-yard distance
  • Waterproof
  • 7 levels of adjustment

  • Potential malfunctions

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here): “I don't know what is up with the other two 1-2 star reviews but I can assure you they are wrong. 1) The longer prongs were included in the box, i'm not sure if he got a knock off or just didn't…”


3Dogtra Fieldmaster 1 Dog LCD Training Collar

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsThird one on the list of best dog training collars is another very well-known company to anybody who's familiar with the industry of dog GPS collars, shock collars for dogs, gun dog supplies and similar.

It's Dogtra, a trusted and reputable brand of various dog supplies helping active owners to train and work with their canines. Dogtra has cornered a good chunk of the training collar market long time ago and still maintains its status as one of the best manufacturers of these devices.

The company has a wide range of dog products for owners to choose from, but one of their flagship devices is the Dogtra Fieldmaster 1, one of the best dog training collars on the market that has proven time and again to effectively train canines without hurting them. This particular device was on the market for years, and at the time of this writing, they're passed with 500 reviews of many online retail platforms with an average rating of 4.7 stars out of 5. That's proof of remarkable achievement in both product design and customer service.

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsAs for the Dogtra Fieldmaster 1 device itself, it comes with a stimulation level (0-27) at a one mile range. Its action modes are delivered through nick, constant, non-stimulating vibrations which is why it's very safe for dogs, and can  be used as anti-bark collar. These tonal levels help owners to use this dog training collar very effectively without harming the dog whatsoever. Obviously, the receiver and transmitter are both waterproof and the LCD screen offers the same amount of correctional level despite the light conditions (dark or bright).

The best part of this device is its battery life in particular, which is something that our #1 best dog training collar pick seemed to struggle with. Fieldmaster 1 lasted a reasonably long time and was easy to charge. The charge period was only a few hours and wasn’t inconvenient to use. This third best dog training collar can be mostly used by dog owners who aren't focused on regular training (non-professionals) and usually train their dogs behaviorally on a daily basis. Overall, it is a long-lasting, high quality, safe piece of equipment.


  • Trusted dog collar brand
  • Constant and non-stimulating vibrations
  • Rechargeable batteries
  • Waterproof (transmitter and receiver)
  • Helpful LCD screen

  • Poor customer service
  • Battery life

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner review (read the full Amazon review here): “I will try and keep this short but I have a thousand good things to say about this product. I have a 15 month old German Shepherd puppy that is roughly 80lbs. He is stubborn and really loves…”

Pro version: Dogtra Field Star 1/2 Mile Remote Trainer

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsOwners who liked the Dogtra Fieldmaster 1 (above), our third one of the best dog training collars, yet found that it may not be the best option for more thorough training, there's a better alternative.

Professional dog trainers recommend these shock collars for dogs for those who know what they are doing, and if used properly, these professional collars can be used for longer and more accurate training of canines. This is Dogtra FieldStar.

There's not much different between this option and the one above, except that all parameters for this professional one are improved slightly. So if you're an owner who's interested in long-term training using electric dog collar, going outdoors with your dog, or you simplyu have a dog that is hard to train, then this alternative to our third one of the best dog training collars is a good option.

Dogtra Field Star is a half a mile remote dog training collar that works within a half-mile range and has rechargeable Ni-MH batteries. The collar and transmitter are waterproof and there is an LCD screen that tracks your dog’s location. There are several levels of vibration and tonal correction and the collar is operated by remote.

This shock collar for dogs is obviously made by the same company that designed the above mentioned device, and is extremely long-lasting while the battery just kept going forever without needing to be charged or adjusted – something all owners and operators could appreciate. It worked on a professional level and holds a charge for a long time, even when working with multiple dogs.


  • Trusted dog collar brand
  • High quality device
  • Very precise stimulation levels (0-27)
  • Nick, non-stimulating vibrations
  • Long batter life

  • Expensive
  • Poor transmitter placement

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“I replaced my sport dog collar with this one and there is no comparison. This training collar is just what I needed for two stubborn American Bulldogs. The range is excellent and…”


4Garmin Delta XC Bundle

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsWe're finally at the last one of the top four companies that are the most trusted brands in the dog shock collar industry. This is Garmin, one of the most recommended best dog training collars, often used by professional dog trainers. Garmin is well-known to many as a manufacturer of car GPS devices as well as many other related products, but they also manufacture dog GPS collars as well as shock collars for dogs.

The truth is – and you'll be able to confirm this when looking at the product's page – Garmin aren't very popular among dog owners wanting an affordable way to train dogs using shock collars. Their primary market are professional dog trainers, and they mainly focus on extremely high end devices that start at around $350 and go up as high as $700 and even $1000s of dollars per device. You can see one of their professional best dog training collars below, which has been proven as one of the best among certified trainers. This, however, does no good for a regular owner who don't need that type of functions, battery life or features.

Nevertheless, Garmin does manufacture smaller and cheaper shock collars for dogs, and their Garmin Delta XC is the most popular package for regular dog owners wanting to train their pets themselves. This electric dog collar has long and short replaceable contact points which work with no issues. Its 18 levels of continuous or momentous stimulation are very effective but may not be as harmless for dogs as those best dog training collars we've mentioned above.

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsThe best part of Garmin Delta XC shock collar is its three different training configurations which help to focus on different behavioral issues in dogs, as well as train up to three canines – all from one handheld device. Another thing you'll quickly notice about this fourth best shock collar for dogs is how sturdy, durable and high quality it feels, looks and works. We know that Garmin manufactures the best car GPS devices, so they've put the same practice into their shock collars for dogs.

Overall, I can say this is a very reliable shock collar for dogs; however, I can't say it's any better than either one of the collars mentioned above. The price is similar, yet features aren't as extensive (although the quality is definitely there, and probably even higher on the scale), and its stimulation levels need a lot more know-how from the owner to make sure not to hurt the dog. It's a great device for a professional dog trainer, but usually, they will opt for Garmin's pro version listed below. So, this product is kind of in a limbo.


  • Very well-known brand
  • High quality device
  • Durable

  • Expensive
  • Lack of features
  • Not as harmless to dogs

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here): “We have a 1.5 year old lab/hound mix who has a great personality, but is highly energetic and headstrong. He is clearly a hunter. Our specific issue was that he wanted to decide…”

Pro version: Garmin Pro 550 Dog Training System

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsWhen compared to the above Garmin dog shock collar, this device is mostly for professional dog trainers or owners who really know what they are doing and truly require all the features of this device. Garmin Pro 550 is easily one of the best dog training collars out there, even though it's not as popular as either one of the mentioned shock collars on our list. This is a professional device with a hefty price tag.

You can train multiple dogs at once with Garmin Pro 550 by purchasing additional devices. The range is one mile and there are different levels of bark correction—21 in total. There is also an option for vibration-only control if you want to use that as your dog’s corrective system. In the kit comes the training system, a collar strap, an adapter, an adapter cable, charging clip, and a few other mechanical necessities to setting up the collar.

Garmin Pro 550 Dog Training System comes with stimulation, tone, and vibration, meaning that whatever you choose to use for your dog is probably going to be the one that is advantageous (versus the one that you have to pick). This device won't stop dog barking but had the most success with recall training, and the correctional levels are widely and conveniently adjustable.

In terms of the drawbacks, there's hardly any, but that depends how you look at shock collars for dogs and what exactly you want from your own device. I'd say one thing that stands out is that the collar was made of a plastic that wasn’t as durable as one may like but there no issues with the product itself.

Overall, Pro 550 is VERY impressive. There are tons of features on this professional collar, such as Barklimiter with advanced dog barking correction technology. Many different types of stimulation levels, all of which can be very easily controlled by using a selection dial on the handheld device.

It's also safer for canines than the above mention Garmin shock collar, because this pro version actually has a regular vibration-only stimulation that is less harmful to dogs, which is particularly useful for owners who don't really know what they're doing yet. This is a full-on professional dog training system with tons of features that comes for an expensive price.


  • Full on dog training system 
  • Professional, high-end dog collar
  • Well known, trusted brand
  • Multi-dog option
  • Vibration-only stimulus
  • Barklimiter with advanced anti-bark tech

  • Expensive
  • Plasticky feel

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“Very satisfied with the results. I have 2 Dogo Argentinos, 1 male 1 female, large, powerful, rough energetic dogs. They play very hard with each other. Rolling around in a rocky desert…”

And this ends our list of truly recommended best dog training collars based on what trainers and experts use for their training, and advise for dog owners to use at home. What follows below in extension of our best dog training collars list are devices that have proven to also be very effective, yet they're not as popular or as recommended by professionals or dog owners alike, or they are simply too expensive and don't fit our price-to-value evaluation, i.e. the high cost of these devices cannot be justified.

However, that doesn't mean they're all-around inferior or should not be looked into. Instead, what we recommend is taking a closer look at these shock collars for dogs below, read customer reviews and compare the features and price tags with the above options to find which dog training collar will work best for you and your pooch.


6 Best Cheap Shock Collars for Dogs as Alternatives

5Garmin Alpha 100 TT 15 Dog GPS Bundle

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsGarmin Alpha 100 TT 15 Dog GPS Bundle contains a high-sensitivity GPS system as well as stimulation levels and tone for correction. There is also a vibration option. The battery life lasts between 20 and 40 hours before needing to be recharged.

This collar is especially good if you’re looking to track and train dogs working in the field—for example, teaching your dog not to run after certain game or other important hunting techniques. There are eighteen levels of stimulation, both continual and momentary, and notifications are sent to the owner to let him or her know when the dog has treed an animal.

Garmin Alpha 100 TT 15 Dog GPS Bundle is on the list of best dog training collars because of its high-levels of correction and variety. You can change the collar to fit any type of dog character that you want. It also shows the dog’s direction and speed as well, both of which are vitally necessary when training your dog as a tracker.

PROS: Garmin Alpha 100 TT is durable and long-lasting. It is also extremely accurate, something that many customers found to be its best feature. It also works well with a dog that has been trained already—the technology is so advanced that dogs that haven’t been trained are likely to struggle with this collar. Above all, customers noted the precision of this system and the ease of setup and use.

CONS: One con that was noted was the shortness of the battery life, which tended to peak at twenty hours. However, if you are able to charge and recharge it easily, that won’t be a problem.

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“Love, love, love this system. I upgraded from the old Astro 220 and there is absolutely no comparison in the quality of the GPS functions. Wish I'd have upgraded sooner! Satellite hookup…”


6SportDOG TEK-V1LT 1.0 GPS+E-Collar

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsSportDOG, a company well-known for making high-quality dog products, created SportDOG TEK-V1LT 1.0 GPS+E-Collar that has a seven-mile tracking range, which is a much larger distance than the other collars discussed. There are up to 100 levels of simulation adjustments available for you to use. This compact collar reports on your dog’s position and the direction that they’re moving in, making this an opportune purchase for owners hunting with their dogs or doing any other outdoor sporting activity.

We chose to place SportDOG TEK-V1LT 1.0 GPS+E-Collar at the middle of this best shock collars for dogs list but isn't at the very top is because a few customers reported that the beeps that were sounded from the collar were ineffectual. There were other concerns that we’ll discuss in the “cons” section of this list.

PROS: This SportDOG TEK-V1LT 1.0 GPS+E-Collar has such a large tracking range that it is convenient for use in pretty much any capacity. Owners who had never trained their dog with an e-collar before and were apprehensive found that SportDOG TEK-V1LT 1.0 GPS+E-Collar worked great and they didn’t have any cause for concern. There’s a tonal level to it that proves to be very effective, even when compared to the static correction.

CONS: Some customers reported issues with reliability and found that their collars weren’t reliable and consistent enough for their usage, especially when it came to the battery life. Experiences varied, however, but it’s something to consider.

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“I had a spaniel mix who passed away in July. I had considered buying an e-training collar for him, but I was apprehensive. I never did, and truth is, he probably didn't need it. BUT, I…”



Garmin Pro Trashbreaker Dog Training System

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsThis handheld device can train multiple dogs at once and operates within a four-mile frequency. Garmin Pro Trashbreaker Dog Training System includes bark correction technology that sends static levels whenever necessary.

You can train with stimulation or tone; whichever works best for your particular dog. There is an LED beacon light feature for dark-light conditions that make your pet visible from up to 100 yards away (useful, especially considering that in hunting conditions, that extra visibility will go a long way).

Garmin Pro Trashbreaker Dog Training System is included on our list of best shock collars for dogs yet not at the top is because although it has the LED light that makes it good for safety reasons, it also doesn’t have as many correctional level adjustments that owners may want.

PROS: The four mile range is a lengthy one and Garmin Pro Trashbreaker Dog Training System was reviewed as being pretty reliable. It also helps make dogs visible at night, something that will make many owners breath sighs of relief about. The range and lights are two of the top selling points, and the tonal correction adds a little variety to it.

CONS: The correctional levels aren’t as adjustable or varied as many owners may have wanted them to be in terms of versatility.

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“Excellent service. Love the lights.in collar. Good range…”


8Super-X 1 Mile Remote Trainer

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsThis dog training collar operates within a one-mile range and contains two-hour lithium batteries optimized for rapid change. There are two settings on Super-X 1 Mile Remote Trainer, either vibration or tonal, to correct your dog.

The receiver and transmitter are waterproof. The screen is LED and gives you your dog’s current location, direction, and the way in which he or she is heading.

Super-X 1 Mile Remote Trainer is eight on the list of best shock collars for dogs because some customers reported reliability issues. Also, the range isn’t as high as some of the other collars we’ve looked at.

PROS: This collar’s LED screen works in both light and dark conditions, which is optimal for owners who take their dogs out for training at different points during the day. The batteries of Super-X 1 Mile Remote Trainer are easy to change, meaning that their short life isn’t an issue.

CONS: The range is short on this (only a mile) and some customers reported issues with the collar faltering in certain static-prone conditions. Also, the correctional levels didn’t have as much variation to them.

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“I am sooo impressed with this training system. I bought this months ago, and use both collars almost daily. They're still going strong on the initial full charge. Unheard of. I started using it…”


9Dogtra EDGE Receiver and Collar

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsDogtra EDGE Receiver and Collar contains built-in lights (LED) on the collar and receiver. The batters are lithium and are two-hour changing. The range is one mile and the correctional levels are either vibration or tonal, depending on what you want to use with your dog.

The battery life of Dogtra EDGE Receiver and Collar was reported as an issue by some customers, although overall, the equipment is still quite high-functioning. This is primarily why it's on the ninth place of our best dog training collars list.

PROS: The batteries are easy to change (though those have their issues, as will be stated in the next subsection). The LED lights of Dogtra EDGE Receiver and Collar are also very helpful for owners who want to make sure that they have an eye on their dogs at all times, even during the night when it’s darker and hard to see. The collar also can work on up to four dogs.

CONS: The batteries had a relatively low—two hour—life cycle, which some customers found disappointing. Also, the range isn’t as vast as it could be—it’s only one mile.

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“This is a VERY well built, well working and rugged unit, both the transmitter and collar. I've not held consumer electronics this well constructed in a long time. The range is fantastic. I have…”


10Garmin Delta Sport XC Bundle

Best Shock Collars for Dogs ReviewsGarmin Delta Sport XC Bundle contains different contact points, both long and short, that you can choose to employ while training your dog. There are several stimulation levels, all workable, and there are 36 different levels of “momentary and continuous” correction for your dog. There is also training options for owners looking to correct how often their dog barks.

Garmin Delta Sport XC Bundle is last on our list of best shock collars for dogs because although it seems like a decent device, some customers found the system to be slow and not responsive enough (see cons section) in comparison to the other reviewed products on this list.

PROS: Customers found that it was especially useful as a bark collar and for training dogs not to nip. The correctional levels of Garmin Delta Sport XC Bundle provided enough variation that they were able to design their dogs training programs without any issues.

CONS: A problem noted with this equipment was the fact sometimes the system took too long to respond. Also, the screen showed brightly at night, so hunting with night vision was disrupted.

Amazon Pet Supplies Reviews Dog ProductsMost helpful dog owner's review (read the full Amazon review here):“As a long time, happy, Tri-Tronics user, I find the changes Garmin has made to be disappointing. With my old remote, and really any remote prior to Garmin, it was easy, and intuitive…”

Best Dog Training Collars

Picking Best Shock Collars for Dogs

When it comes to training your dog, you can never be too prepared. There are many different ways to train a dog, many of which involve behavioral techniques and equipment combined. One of the popular ways is through using the best dog training collars that are safe for dogs.

After interviewing and discussing best dog training collars with many trainers, dog experts and specialists in this field, collecting responses and reviews from dog owners and doing our own research on different types of training collars for dogs on the market, we have finally put together this master list of the top 10 best dog training collars of high quality and premium build based on their accuracy.

Dog shock collars have been a controversial subject as of late. However, dog training experts advocate that if you know what you're doing, and you purchase the highest quality dog training collar, then no harm will ever be done to a dog. That makes sense, and studies as well as dog trainers have proved this to be true time and again.

These best dog training collars are high-functioning and very high-quality; they’ll ensure that you have a smooth experience with training your dog without causing any harm. All of the electric dog collars are humane and, when combined with decent behavioral training, are sure to give you the best results when it comes to your beloved dog. In the end, we still need to train our canines, and this is an effective method.

The key to learning how to train a dog and do it successfully, in addition to determination and consistency on your part, is a product that won’t let you down and will serve humanely to correct any problematic behavior that could endanger your dog if he or she continued with it. In the above list of top ten best dog training collars for dogs, you see our overview of some of the best dog collars on the market where we analyze their pros and cons, and provide a sufficient amount of information on each of our selections for the top training collars for dogs so that you can make the right choice yourself.

Best Dog Training Collars Safe for Dogs

What are dog training collars?

Not every dog owner learning how to train a dog is familiar with training collars for dogs. This device is only now gaining popularity as the go-to product for effectively teaching canines the most important techniques and behaviors. Training dog collars (also known as e-collars for dogs, dog shock collars, electric collars for dogs and so forth) are canine collars that attach around your dog’s neck and provide a level of static and/or tonal correction that is administered whenever your dog exhibits a detrimental behavior.

This approach for training dogs seeks to use negative reinforcement to achieve behavioral training. The levels of static are humane and nothing more than a slight discomfort to your dog—one that won’t harm them, but that won’t be enjoyable either. There's a lot of controversy and poor information surrounding the use of dog shock collars, because people associate the word “shock” as if it's a torture for the pet, or as if the owners deliberately want to cause harm to the dog. This couldn't be further from the truth, and you can read the interview with one of the most well-known dog trainers on why that is (linked above).

However, it's important that you have all the information at your hand on how to train a dog using these collars, and particularly if you decide not to use them for whatever reason. We've covered the topics of how to avoid using shock collars and still be able to train dogs without them, so I also encourage you to read a couple of our articles that you may find helpful and possibly will help to make a better decision with your future training dog collar:

  1. No More Pain: Best Alternatives to Dog Shock Collars
  2. How to Deal With Dog Aggression Without Training Collars

Now getting back to topic on the best dog training collars, it's important for the owners to understand that these devices are an efficient way to improve upon your canine's behavior. Often, dogs exhibit behavior that can actually harm the dog itself in the long run (such as running out into the street or getting too close to dangerous things that can hurt them). You want to make sure that the lesson you teach your dog is humane and firm and will potentially save their lives one day. Training dog collars provide you, the owner, with the discretion and control you need to ensure that your dog is being obedient and not causing harm to him or herself or others.

Best Shock Collars for Dogs for Dog TrainingSome of these training collars for dogs we mention in the article come in a variety of different machinations and levels. Manufacturers of these best dog training collars know that different dogs need different things, so they generally make the levels or static and/or tonal correction adjustable and maneuverable for the dog’s owner to fiddle with to get the best level possible.

Many dog experts and certified dog trainers agree that the use of best dog training collars is not meant to be permanent, or rather to stay permanently on your canine's neck. They’re a tool for behavioral obedience, and dog training collars not considered a permanent measure. Even though you won’t be using your dog training collar permanently, you want to make sure that the dog shock collar you choose is high-quality and won’t fizzle out on you or damage your canine in any way.

The list we’ve compiled above is based off of interviews, questions to dog experts and trainers, many hours of research, dog owners' reviews, experiences, thorough analysis of training collars' features and careful investigation of a particular e-collar equipment's quality and its risk factors. In the above list of best dog training collars we attempt to demonstrate you our results on the best training dog collars and hope that they give you all the information you need to select the right piece of equipment for your own Fido.

How to choose the best dog training collar?

There are multiple factors to consider when picking best dog training collars for your dogs. These factors are dependent on both you the owner, and your dog. You want to make sure that a feature any of these best shock dog collars has is its adjust-ability. If a dog training collar doesn’t have this feature, it runs the risk of being inhumane and ineffective.

We know that dog collars that are adjustable allow you to decide what the correction level will be. A big part of that decision depends on the sensitivity of your dog. Too high a correction level is cruel, but too low won’t have any effect at all. Being able to freely decide what the correction level should be on your e-collar allows you as the owner to have full control over the behavioral training and to avoid any mishaps.

Best Shock Collar for DogsKnow whether or not you want your own best dog training collar to have a tonal option in addition to the static correction one. Some owners prefer to solely use a high, unpleasant tone on their electric collars instead of a static. If you’re an owner who would like to start with or try an option other than the static, check to be sure that the collar you choose operates tonally as well.

Remember that these best dog training collars only assist in canine's behavioral training and shouldn’t be used as a sole source of guidance when choosing your dog’s training experience. If you want to learn how to train a dog, then these products should be used alongside proper training program. These collars are in addition to positive reinforcement and other methods which should always be a focal point of your dog training routine. You don’t want to rely too heavily on dog shock collars or any other similar electric dog devices for that matter, as that will be beneficial for no one.

Make sure that the best dog training collar of your choosing is reliable.

Reliability ensures safety. The ten best dog training collars we listed for you above were all reviewed and decided to work on a consistent power source without accidental unnecessary corrective jolts. The batteries should be easy to replace and long-lasting so that you’re not running out to the store every other week. Training dog collars without this reliability feature are at risk of being inhumane, useless and harmful to dogs.

Know your dog’s neck measurements before choosing any of these best dog training collars.

Although this should be self-explanatory, you want to make sure that you’re buying the right sized collar for the right breed. Weight is important as well in how well the collar will work. Understand your dog’s temperament. Some dogs are nervous and won’t be able to handle a behavioral regimen that contains negative reinforcement. Though these dogs are a small minority, it certainly is something to think about when selecting your shock dog collar.

Our above list of ten best dog training collars contains product information and evaluation (pros and cons) that will help you make the best decision about which training dog collar to select. When purchasing something, it’s important to look not only at the material aspects of it (overview), but what people are saying as well.

The old saying goes that people tend to tell the truth most when they’re angry or drunk, but we believe there’s another addendum to that saying: people have no incentive to lie when they’re taking the time to review a product that they really liked or disliked. In that vein, we gave you full overview of what we thought to be the top-of-the-line best dog training collars and included links to dog collar reviews from other customers so that you can gather additional input on the matter.

We certainly hope this list of best dog training collars will help you pick the right and – most importantly – SAFE product for your pet. We also want to make sure that you are aware that we are not sponsored by any of the manufacturers or dog companies mentioned in this article. Please note that we do our best to provide accurate information, but we highly encourage dog owners to always double-check other sources for additional tips on best dog training collars so that you can make a more accurate decision of what’s best for your pet.

The above overview of best shock dog collars should give pet owners a good idea of the highest quality products that should be safest for dogs. However, please also make sure that you read and research more dog shock collars reviews from other dog owners and educate yourself on how to train a dog using dog training collars, just to understand how the process works and what it's like to use these devices.

Disclosure: We may earn affiliate commissions at no cost to you from the links on this page. This did not affect our assessment of products. Read more here and find full disclosure here.


  1. As a balanced trainer, I am happy to see a pro E-collar article. I must admit though, I highly disagree with the notion that “expensive” dog collars are totally safe.
    Have you ever felt the full shock of any e-collar, including the ones you have listed?
    If used incorrectly, they can be extremely painful and traumatic for a dog.
    E-collars are a great tool for most balanced dog trainers but should not be left in the hands of the general public without instruction for proper use.
    It takes knowledge, skill and an educated understanding of dog behavior to be able to use an electronic collar properly. It should only be used in a way that leaves a dog feeling empowered and enthusiastic about learning. If misused or used incorrectly, the dog could suffer severe long term mental effects.
    I urge you to, at the minimum, include a disclosure advising pet parents to consult with a professional, properly trained in e-collar conditioning.
    A balanced dog trainer

    • Hello, Shauna.

      Thank you for your thorough and clever contribution. These are very good points!

      I would like to invite you to send us a message (email below in the footer) to discuss this topic further and possibly help us inform the owners further. We would greatly appreciate your input!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here