As dog owners we know that training our pups can sometimes be a frustrating job. That’s why there are so many different canine training tools to help us with this task, including vibrating dog collars which are the perfect choice for pet owners who are not happy with using shock collars to train their dogs.
In this article, I will explain what vibrating dog collars are and what they do, what to look for when you're looking to buy one and how to use them effectively. We will also review our top 10 favorite best vibrating dog collar brands for pets with training difficulties.
What Are Vibrating Dog Collars?
Conceptually, vibrating dog collars are similar to shock collars in how they assist owners in training canines, except they don’t produce electricity (and don't hurt the dog) but instead use vibration to get the dog’s attention and correct his behavior.
In most cases, these can also be sold as shock dog collars that also come with a vibration mode. Thus, you can buy a shock collar but never use the shock option and only stick with the non-harming vibration. Generally, these training collars are used for sensitive or deaf dogs but many dog owners choose them over shock collars out of principle.
Some of the most popular and best vibrating dog collar brands are these five:
No products found.
How to Use a Vibrating Dog Collar?
It is important to fit the collar correctly first, and then attach the collar properly, which means that it should be tight enough for the dog to feel the vibrations, but not too tight to be uncomfortable or cause choking. You should be able to slip one or two fingers between your dog’s neck and his new collar.
Your dog may need some time to get used to wearing it because vibrating collars (and shock collars) are usually heavier than regular dog collars, but the pup will get accustomed to it eventually. Start with putting the collar on for a short period of time (e.g. 15-30 minutes for a couple of days). When you do it, reward your pooch with a treat. Gradually increase the time the collar stays on until your dog is fully comfortable with it before you introduce the vibrations.
How to Choose a Good Vibrating Dog Collar?
If you decide you need the help of a vibrating dog collar in your puppy training, there are a few things to consider before you go out and make the purchase. We've considered all of these and other factors in choosing the best vibrating dog collar brands.
The most important factor you need to consider is the size of your dog’s neck. Before you buy any pet collar, measure the dimensions of his neck (best taken about an inch below the neck, depending on your dog’s size). Remember, the pet collar should not be attached too tight or be too loose. Look for collars that are more adjustable since that makes it easier to fit them properly on most dogs.
Dog collars are usually made from ribbon or fabrics like nylon, hemp and leather. Nylon collars are a good choice for chewers because it is more durable than the other materials. Leather dog collars are better in quality and can be quite stylish. They are also extremely durable but they are also more expensive than other options. Faux letter is cheap but breaks down easy.
One of the best materials overall is neoprene, which is basically soft rubber reinforced with nylon webbing to provide additional durability and strength. However, when it comes to vibrating dog collars, your options are more limited in what material is used for the collar itself.
Technology that comes with vibrating collars is one of the biggest factors to consider because they all have similar features and even the smallest difference needs to be taken into account. These features include different modes, simulation levels, safety protections, LCD screens and battery life, among others.
Some of the collars can also trigger a static shock or use sound in addition to vibrations. Some of them have a bigger range, others have more adjustment levels. Many models are focused solely on barking and work automatically to prevent it but there are other models that come with a remote and can be used for more extensive training.
Prices for vibrating dog collars range from $20 to over $100, depending on things like the range of distance, presence and type of remote control, additional settings, quality of the material, etc. However, the price doesn’t always accurately reflect the quality and you can often find good deals for great products, especially if you shop online.
Now that you know what to look for when you choose a vibrating dog collar, let's take a look at some of the best vibrating dog collars that are worth the cost and are effective.
The Best Vibrating Dog Collar Brands
1. SportDOG FieldTrainer SD-425
SportDOG brand is the most known to dog trainers and hunters, and their best vibrating dog collar is one of the most popular in the market, which is reflected in its very steep price. This product covers an impressive range of 500 yards, or 1500 feet. Both the remote and receiver are waterproof and can go as deep as 25 feet.
No products found.
The collar fits dogs 8 pounds or larger and can cover neck sizes in the range of 5″ – 22″, which is actually not suitable for the largest dogs. This device allows you to use three different training modes – static, vibration and tone, with 7 levels of static stimulation.
You can use the remote to train up to three dogs if you get additional receivers. You can also customize the buttons on the remote to your liking. The remote and receiver come with rechargeable batteries that last for 50-70 hours before you have to recharge them again. They also come with a low-battery indicator to let you know when it is time for a recharge.
Once again, some users reported that the product didn’t work properly and wasn’t effective, although those were not common complaints.
PROS: Three Training Modes, Waterproof, Durable, Can Be Used for 3 Dogs, Great Range, Rechargeable, Good Battery Life
CONS: Not Suitable for Extremely Large Dogs, Some Reports of Not Being Effective, Expensive
2. Dogwidgets DW-3 E-Collar
This electronic collar features one strong vibration and 6 different levels of shock stimulation options. The vibration level is effective and strong, but it is also safe for your pooch. The size of the collar can range from 12 to 20 inches long and can fit on all dogs from 15 to 100 pounds.
No products found.
The collar comes with a rechargeable receiver, which is also water-resistant (not waterproof!). There are also some innovative features that save battery life, like Power Saver mode and Auto Sleep feature. The device can cover the range of up to 600 feet, which is on the lower end of the spectrum.
This collar comes with a simple remote control that has 7 separate buttons for vibrations and shock levels, so you don’t have to switch between them. The 9-volt battery in the remote is also rechargeable, so you won’t have to spend extra for new batteries.
The price is one of the main selling points for this collar. However, many users reported malfunctions after a certain time. Some reported that the collar stopped working but some dog owners said that it started delivering shocks all the time or randomly without instructions, which can be a serious problem if you are not close to your dog.
PROS: Adjustable Collar, Rechargeable, Simple and Intuitive Remote, Affordable Price, Two Training Modes
CONS: Not Very Durable, Numerous Malfunction Reports, Short Range, Not Suitable for Small or Very Large Breeds
3. DT Systems IDT-PLUS Micro Dog Trainer
This dog collar has 16 levels of static stimulation, including continuous, momentary, gentle, etc. In addition to this, it also has a positive vibration mode. With add-on collar units, which are sold separately, you can train up to 3 dogs with one remote.
No products found.
The collar is completely waterproof, although some users reported that some parts weren’t. Both transmitter and remote are rechargeable, with a battery life of 1-2 weeks, depending on use. This collar is adjustable and can fit most dogs, except the largest breeds since it covers neck sizes from 7 to 22 inches.
This device has a built-in safety system and boasts digital technology to maximize power. It is compact and lightweight because it weighs around 4 ounces. It can also cover an impressive range of up to 900 yards.
Some users reported transmission problems with multiple dogs and that the battery life is shorter than advertised.
PROS: Compact, Adjustable Collar, Waterproof, Can Be Used to Train 3 Dogs, Two Training Modes, Digital Technology, Impressive Range, Rechargeable
CONS: Expensive, Not Suitable for Largest Breeds, Reports of Not Being Fully Waterproof, Reports of Transmission Problems for Multiple Dogs
4. iPets Rechargeable Collar
This device is essentially a shock collar that comes with additional training modes like audible beeps and vibration. The range is limited at short 660 feet, which is not at par with some other collars. The collar itself is adjustable and can fit even the smallest dogs.
No products found.
Unlike most collar remotes that require pressing a button multiple times in order to increase the intensity of stimulation, this device uses a precise intensity dial instead. You only have to adjust the dial and then choose the desired mode.
This collar is waterproof, while the remote is water resistant. The entire device is one rechargeable unit, which means that you recharge both the remote and collar at the same time. You can use the remote control for two collars.
Unfortunately, this collar doesn’t have an indicator that displays low battery life. Also, many users reported problems with the range of the collar and claimed that it doesn’t even cover the listed 660 feet. Other dog owners reported durability issues, saying that their device broke down after using it for a short time.
PROS: Three Training Modes, Adjustable Collar, Waterproof, User-Friendly Remote, Can Be Used for 2 Dogs, Rechargeable, Affordable Price
CONS: Not Very Durable, Short Range, Malfunction Reports, No Battery Life Indicator
5. Dogtra IQ-Plus Remote Trainer
This is one of the most expensive items on our list, which is not fully justified even though this is a great collar. It covers 400 yards, so there are vibrating collars with a bigger range. The collar is plastic and easily adjustable, so it’s suitable for dogs over 10 pounds.
No products found.
The receiver is fully waterproof, well-built and truly compact. This product comes with 2-hour rapid charge batteries, which is unique. However, some users reported problems with the charging process, especially after a few months of use.
Unlike other competitors in a similar price range, Dogtra IQ Plus can only accommodate two dogs with one remote. It also comes without tone training mode, with static and vibration as only two options. However, it does allow you to convert it to a vibration-only collar with included nylon contact points.
PROS: Adjustable Collar, Compact, Medium Range, Can Be Used for 2 Dogs, Rapid-Charge Batteries, Two Training Modes
CONS: Very Expensive, No Tone Training Mode, Some Reports of Charger Problems, Some Reports of Malfunction
6. Dog Care Training Collar
Even though it is one of the more affordable options on the market, this training collar comes with some impressive features. The one that truly stands out is the ability to control up to 9 dogs with a single remote. It also comes with three training modes and static levels that range from 0 to 99.
No products found.
The receiver is waterproof and the remote has a security keypad lock that prevents accidental shocks or vibrations. Batteries are rechargeable and can last up to 15 days on the receiver and up to 45 days on the remote, depending on the use. The collar is adjustable and suitable for dogs that weigh from 15 to 100 pounds.
The signal range for this device is limited at 330 yards, right where you would expect it to be considering the price. However, there are reports that say that this collar is not suitable for dogs with thick fur, while some dog owners complained about a rapid decline in battery life after a while, as well as charger problems.
PROS: Affordable, Medium Range, Rechargeable, Adjustable Collar, Can Control up to 9 Dogs, Three Training Modes, Security Keypad Lock
CONS: Not Suitable for Extra Small or Extra Large Breeds, Reports of Charger and Battery Problems, Reports of Ineffectiveness on Dogs with Tick Fur
7. TBI Pro Rechargeable Bark Collar
This bark collar has one function – to prevent your dog from barking and correct his barking behavior. The collar comes with 5 different levels of sensitivity and three different training modes, including vibration. High-tech design is evident in the digital screen where you can see and set training mode and intensity.
No products found.
The collar is lightweight, waterproof and has a rechargeable battery which can last up to 14 days without charging. It can also fit most dogs since it is suitable for dogs that weigh anywhere from 7 to 120 pounds.
This device has an intelligent barking detection system that prevents false triggering. That means that barking from other dogs can’t trigger the collar, so your pooch won’t get punished without reason. However, some users reported that the false protection is not effective and that the collar gets triggered by other dogs barking.
This device also comes with an automatic safety mode, which can deactivate the collar if it gets triggered 7 times in one minute. However, there are some dog owners who reported that this device was not really effective and that it requires assembling, which could have been simpler.
PROS: Lightweight, Waterproof, Rechargeable, Three Training Modes, Safety Mode, False Protection, Adjustable Collar, Affordable Price
CONS: Requires Assembly, Reports of Ineffectiveness, Reports of False Protection Not Working Properly, Reports of Charging Problems
8. BARKLO Vibrating Dog Collar
This is an automatic vibrating collar meant to correct undesired barking behavior. Unlike similar models, this one doesn’t have prongs, which often irritate some dogs. In addition to vibrations, this collar also triggers audible tones to deliver multi-sensory stimulation.
No products found.
When the collar detects first bark from your pooch, it triggers a brief audio tone. A second bark triggers a longer tone, while the third bark activates the vibration circuitry to go with the sound. It gradually increases the length of the vibration and tone up to stage 7, when Sleep Mode gets activated for a minute before the entire process starts again.
The collar is waterproof, compact, rechargeable and designed for tiny dogs that weigh as little as 6 pounds, to dogs of medium size. It is adjustable and can fit on dogs with a neck size from 5 to 19 inches. Unfortunately, many dog owners reported that the device was not working and couldn’t help them with excessive barking.
PROS: Adjustable Collar, Fits on the Smallest Breeds, Waterproof, Rechargeable, Two Modes, Sleep Mode, Affordable Price
CONS: Not Suitable for Large Breeds, Reports of Malfunction, Reports of Ineffectiveness, Manual Hard to Understand
9. Petrainer PET998DRB Rechargeable Dog Collar
This model comes with static, beep and vibration modes, as well as stimulation levels that range from 1-100. The remote range is in the middle of the spectrum at around 1000 feet, which is not too bad for the very affordable price.
No products found.
While this collar is not waterproof and can’t be used in water, both the receiver and remote are water resistant. They are also both rechargeable, although some users said that the batteries need to be charged often.
The collar is made of nylon and can be adjusted to fit neck sizes from 15 to 22 inches and dogs who weigh more than 15 pounds. However, this means that it is not suitable for small dogs, or the largest breeds.
This is one of the most popular vibration collars on Amazon thanks to the price and good features but there are also many reports of parts that are falling off and malfunctions that rendered the device ineffective.
PROS: Affordable Price, Medium Range, Water Resistant, Adjustable Collar, Rechargeable, Three Training Modes
CONS: Not Suitable for Smallest or Largest Breeds, Reports of Disintegrating Parts, Reports of Malfunction, Can’t Be Expanded to Include Multiple Dogs, Low Battery Life
10. Aolun Remote Training Collar for Dogs
This collar comes with three different training modes. It can be used as a shock, beep or vibration collar, with 100 levels of intensity. The receiver is sturdy, waterproof and equipped with LCD display. The distance range on this device is at a good 1000 feet.
No products found.
The collar has an adjustable belt, which makes it suitable for dogs of all sizes. It also comes with a remote that has a rechargeable battery. If the collar is not used for over 2 minutes, it goes into the Hibernation Mode to preserve the battery.
This device is at the lower spectrum when it comes to price, so it’s affordable to most dog owners. However, some dog owners are not satisfied with the intensity of it, saying that their dogs don’t really feel the vibrations. Others also reported that the collar stopped working shortly after they received it.
PROS: Affordable Price, Three Training Modes, Medium Range, Waterproof, Rechargeable, Hibernation Mode, Medium Range
CONS: Not Very Durable, Reports of Not Being Effective, Reports of Malfunction
There are many good options on the market for vibrating dog collars and you can find one that suits your needs perfectly, whether you are looking for an automatic bark deterrent and correction device or you want a remote training collar to correct other types of unwanted behavior.
When you shop for a good vibrating dog collar, consider factors like size of the collar and how it would fit your dog, levels of stimulation, range of the remote, price, material and other technical specifications like the type of display, and battery life.
You'll notice that many listed best vibrating dog collar brands are labeled as electronic shock collars, which they are; however, you don't have to use the shock option. Simply ignore that part of the collar and stick with vibrations only to train your pooch.